Using AI to analyse tuning logs
-
antus
- Site Admin
- Posts: 10111
- Joined: Sat Feb 28, 2009 10:34 am
- cars: TX Gemini 2L Twincam 8psi
TX Gemini SR20 18psi
Datsun 1200 Ute
Subaru Blitzen '06 EZ30 4th gen, 3.0R Spec B
Subaru WRX 2007
Re: Using AI to analyse tuning logs
I might be assuming the knock detection in the logs is accurate. Perhaps give it the community wisdom that the knock sense in 12P is not effective and not to trust it. I'd be more inclined to use it for mixture, injector and idle correction and similar than spark. At least keep it to suggestions and its reasoning instead of actual advancement in the spark table.
Have you read the FAQ? For lots of information and links to significant threads see here: http://pcmhacking.net/forums/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=1396
-
Charlescrown
- Posts: 2097
- Joined: Fri Aug 05, 2011 9:58 pm
- cars: V8 VR Commodore BT1
LB Lancer 2L turbo & Delco
Starion TBI with Delco
Mitsubishi Lancer EVO4 track car
NA MX5
3 vintage motor bikes - Location: Padstow NSW
Re: Using AI to analyse tuning logs
The problem is there is no knock detection in the log and and the csv conversion so if there's not the slightest of it anywhere how can AI determine there is. It's only looking at the log nothing else.
-
antus
- Site Admin
- Posts: 10111
- Joined: Sat Feb 28, 2009 10:34 am
- cars: TX Gemini 2L Twincam 8psi
TX Gemini SR20 18psi
Datsun 1200 Ute
Subaru Blitzen '06 EZ30 4th gen, 3.0R Spec B
Subaru WRX 2007
Re: Using AI to analyse tuning logs
Exactly, so that doesn't mean it cant tune spark if you add a 3rd party knock sensor or dyno control for it to look for MBT timing, but it does mean it's got no data to work with now so you can't assume it'll be safe without guard rails. And having said that i'd be a hesitant to let an AI control a heavy machine like a dyno. Getting that right and safe would take thought and planning with effective failsafes.
Have you read the FAQ? For lots of information and links to significant threads see here: http://pcmhacking.net/forums/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=1396
-
vlad01
- Posts: 8600
- Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2012 8:41 am
- cars: VP I S
VP I executive
VP II executive
VP II executive #2 - Location: Kyneton, Vic
Re: Using AI to analyse tuning logs
MBT and knock aren't usually related, sometimes an engine is knock limited well before MBT, other ones only knock when well past MBT, some might do so right on the limit, and all this changes with altitude, air temps, fuel type etc... Spark is one that will rely on more than just knock. Maybe AI can figure it out from map kpa vs other inputs were it could maybe pickup on increase/decrease of kpa (vac) and find the max vac for each load point against the other inputs. But the dyno really is the best way as it measures torque directly.
-
antus
- Site Admin
- Posts: 10111
- Joined: Sat Feb 28, 2009 10:34 am
- cars: TX Gemini 2L Twincam 8psi
TX Gemini SR20 18psi
Datsun 1200 Ute
Subaru Blitzen '06 EZ30 4th gen, 3.0R Spec B
Subaru WRX 2007
Re: Using AI to analyse tuning logs
Agree. It's really no different to doing it without AI, but AI is the tool and you need it or the program it creates to be able to see what is going on to do the job. For a dyno that's all the same things the human needs when they're doing it including good knock detection. Though AI might be able to do a good job with just a piezo sensor wired to a sound card and software filtering on the PC.
Have you read the FAQ? For lots of information and links to significant threads see here: http://pcmhacking.net/forums/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=1396
-
Charlescrown
- Posts: 2097
- Joined: Fri Aug 05, 2011 9:58 pm
- cars: V8 VR Commodore BT1
LB Lancer 2L turbo & Delco
Starion TBI with Delco
Mitsubishi Lancer EVO4 track car
NA MX5
3 vintage motor bikes - Location: Padstow NSW
Re: Using AI to analyse tuning logs
I have a good noise tester I made many years ago and will wear it when logging. I do know abt Maximum torque and knock with some cars going way past the max with no knock but the diagnosis of the log was specific in some of the data so from past AI replies getting conflicting info will say yes it's been beneficial in some areas but not others. All AI can do is research online data hoping for the best. On 2 occasions I asked for ignition timing maps and got 2 very different reply's.
-
Muncie
- Posts: 249
- Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2020 6:15 am
- cars: Vy commodore, Turbo Ecotec v6
- Location: New Zealand Waikato
Re: Using AI to analyse tuning logs
Been using it for tuning as well mainly i had the car running ok ish didn't start well ran rich and had a little bit of knock retard happening. Ive now fixed all of the Above and retuned it from 100 octane back to 95 octane as that was what got the knock retard under control good fuel.
It now runs much cleaner and drives far better the tune is conservative as far as timing goes but it just doesnt knock anymore or ever get warm so all in all im very happy.
By far thing im happiest with is the traction control and transmission adjustments made, my 500,000 4L60E its handling a built turbo l67 on 12psi and doesn't slip at 18psi either traction control is now progressive instead of a faceplant.
It now runs much cleaner and drives far better the tune is conservative as far as timing goes but it just doesnt knock anymore or ever get warm so all in all im very happy.
By far thing im happiest with is the traction control and transmission adjustments made, my 500,000 4L60E its handling a built turbo l67 on 12psi and doesn't slip at 18psi either traction control is now progressive instead of a faceplant.
-
Charlescrown
- Posts: 2097
- Joined: Fri Aug 05, 2011 9:58 pm
- cars: V8 VR Commodore BT1
LB Lancer 2L turbo & Delco
Starion TBI with Delco
Mitsubishi Lancer EVO4 track car
NA MX5
3 vintage motor bikes - Location: Padstow NSW
Re: Using AI to analyse tuning logs
I was thinking of running the log with AI again to see if it can tell me where it happened. It told me what was happening at the time with some data but not the position. The reason is it did backfire once during the log which it may have interpreted what looked like a knock from other data. I do have around 4 degrees more timing than my other car but it's running more boost and does show small amounts of knock in a log. Just gotta keep big foot off the accelerator till I sort it out.